Back before Uber and Nude boobsLyft ride-sharing (yes, there was a time!), hailing a regular cab didn't always guarantee a ride. In San Francisco, for instance, drivers would often deny passengers rides to neighborhoods on the far west side of the city, or across the Bay, or Golden Gate Bridge. Then Uber and Lyft came along, and drivers were none the wiser as to where you were headed until they'd already accepted the ride and you were in the backseat. Oakland here we come!
But changes to the Uber driver app, introduced this week for California drivers, would let drivers officially reject ride requests. Eventually, all California drivers will see trip information including destination, estimated ride time and mileage, ride type, and potential earnings range. At the moment, only about a third of drivers in the state have the new feature. By mid-January, every driver will be able to see destination information. Riders, however, won't actually know if a potential ride match was denied because it'll happen before a driver accepts a ride. But even though that will all happen behind the scenes, riders could still be left waiting for a ride match to an "undesirable" destination, like a faraway place or inconvenient airport drop-off.
An Uber spokesperson said in an email the company "can't speculate on marketplace impact." But those long waits are still a possibility. Even if there are about 200,000 California-based Uber drivers, destination information could dissuade drivers from certain rides. In Atlanta, a local news report this week found that ride-share drivers consider certain parts of the city to be "no-go zones." This exact type of discrimination is why Uber doesn't let drivers in that metro area see the destination until passengers are picked up.
Uber clearly is aware that giving all of that destination information is likely to lead to, um, let's call it "selective" ride acceptance. So it reminded drivers that rejecting rides based on location is a violation of its guidelines and California law. For anyone who needs a refresher on local discrimination laws, the Unruh Civil Rights Act states all Californians "are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever."
Despite these legal protections, there's little recourse for passengers who are, unknowingly, denied rides by this new change. Only Uber will be able to track if certain areas are suddenly less popular for drop-offs. Mucking up the issue even further, rejected rides will no longer negatively impact a driver's Uber Pro rewards profile. Canceled trips, however, still count toward driver ratings.
The changes are all set to coincide with a new California employment classification law, known as AB5, which goes into effect mid-January. Under this law, gig-based companies will have to prove workers are truly independentcontractors. Otherwise, companies like Uber will be forced to start treating them as employees. Uber's thinking seems to follow that, with more upfront information for drivers, they'll need to rely less on Uber itself and the app. This then bolsters the ride-share company's argument that drivers are independent workers and you can "be your own boss."
For drivers, these changes are mostly welcome. It means more flexibility and upfront information with little accountability if they are indeed discriminating against riders because of location. One former driver wrote on the Rideshare Guy blog, "Not knowing the driver destination was LITERALLY the reason I quit driving as soon as I did. I just felt cheated all the time and couldn't deal with it."
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
Competing ride-share service Lyft, on the other hand, is keeping its driver information the same as usual: Drivers still won't see the destination, but are shown the ride type, rider rating, and other details, like ride duration for 45-minute-plus trips. Only "select" (Lyft doesn't divulge much more on who is selected beyond drivers in certain cities with high acceptance rates) drivers have a "Destination on Accept" feature which tells them which direction they'll be headed and estimated trip time before officially accepting the trip. So, for example, if a driver in downtown San Francisco gets a request for a 25-minute trip east of the city, they can decide if they want to leave the city limits or not.
To counter any ideas about location-based discrimination on its end, Lyft cites a 44-percent pick-up or drop-off rate in low-income areas across its service areas in both the U.S. and Canada.
So even though these new driver features could possibly open up a whole can of discriminatory worms, there's still a silver lining for California riders: At least you can ride guilt-free knowing your driver willinglyand knowinglyaccepted your ride. Oakland here we come (again)!
Topics Uber
NYT Connections hints and answers for November 26: Tips to solve 'Connections' #534.Best Black Friday Apple Watch SE 40mm deal: Get $100 off for Black FridayEarly Black Friday Apple Watch deals: Series 10, 9, and SE down to record lows55 of the best early Black Friday deals on headphones and speakers from Bose, Sony, and JBLBest Black Friday Sticker Printer deal: Save 43% at AmazonBest Black Friday power station deal: Anker SOLIX C1000X Portable Power Station for $426Red Star Belgrade vs. Stuttgart 2024 livestream: Watch Champions League for freeBest Black Friday mattress deal: Save up to 50% on DreamCloudBest Black Friday gaming laptop deal: Save $300 on ASUS ROG Strix G16Thanksgiving dinner from Dollar Tree? TikTok creator going viral for her $20 holiday mealBest Black Friday TV deals at Amazon: A few cheap Fire TVs on saleBest Black Friday Sticker Printer deal: Save 43% at AmazonParamount+ Black Friday deal: Slash 76% off two months of streamingThe internet doesn’t like the new iOS 18 Photos app redesign — how to fix itBest PS5 Black Friday deals: Compare Best Buy, Amazon, Target, and moreEarly Black Friday keyboard deals for daily use and gamingBest Black Friday gaming laptop deal: Save $300 on ASUS ROG Strix G16Xbox Series X deal: $398 at WalmartWhy is Drake suing UMG and Spotify over Kendrick Lamar?Sporting Lisbon vs. Arsenal 2024 livestream: Watch Champions League for free Florida hasn't had a hurricane in 3,965 days: until today 'Overwatch' season 2 is live for all players with new map and hero changes Coming to Amazon in September: Woody Allen series, 'Transparent' Season 3 and more Anybody wanna buy a $3,200 Sony Walkman? One of those naked Trump statues could be yours Mom and toddler's 'potty time' song is way too catchy Chris Brown releases new song less than a day after his arrest Social senior dog walks 4 miles every day to catch up with all his friends New Withings fitness watch adds heart rate sensor and notifications Samsung will replace more than 2.5 million Galaxy Note7 devices Wave of '90s throwback tours proves the nostalgia cycle is in full effect What to do with your possibly explosive Galaxy Note7 After nearly 50 years of employment, librarian leaves $4 million to university after death Tinder crashed and now love is dead This Poké Ball phone battery is perfect for hardcore 'Pokémon Go' players Sony's Xperia Agent robot is a cute, friendly smart Did Tesla's Model X software update make its falcon Why Tropical Storm Hermine poses a menacing flood, erosion risk to Mid Solange Knowles wraps herself in yarn, still inspires outfit envy Jon Favreau joins Marvel's 'Spider