The The Liar (2014)first look a Twitter user gets at a tweet might be an unintentionally racially biased one.
Twitter said Sunday that it would investigate whether the neural network that selects which part of an image to show in a photo preview favors showing the faces of white people over Black people.
The trouble started over the weekend when Twitter users posted several examples of how, in an image featuring a photo of a Black person and a photo of a white person, Twitter's preview of the photo in the timeline more frequently displayed the white person.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
The public tests got Twitter's attention - and now the company is apparently taking action.
"Our team did test for bias before shipping the model and did not find evidence of racial or gender bias in our testing," Liz Kelly, a member of the Twitter communications team, told Mashable. "But it’s clear from these examples that we’ve got more analysis to do. We're looking into this and will continue to share what we learn and what actions we take."
Twitter's Chief Design Officer Dantley Davis and Chief Technology Officer Parag Agrawal also chimed in on Twitter, saying they're "investigating" the neural network.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
The conversation started when one Twitter user initially posted about racial bias on Zoom's facial detection. He noticed that the side-by-side image of him (a white man) and his Black colleague repeatedly showed his face in previews.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
After multiple users got in on testing, one user even showed how the favoring of lighter faces was the case with characters from The Simpsons.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
Twitter's promise to investigate is encouraging, but Twitter users should view the analyses with a grain of salt. It's problematic to claim incidences of bias from a handful of examples. To really assess bias, researchers need a large sample size with multiple examples under a variety of circumstances.
Anything else is making claims of bias by anecdote – something conservatives do to claim anti-conservative bias on social media. These sorts of arguments can be harmful because people can usually find one or two examples of just about anything to prove a point, which undermines the authority of actually rigorous analysis.
That doesn't mean the previews question is not worth looking into, as this could be an example of algorithmic bias: When automated systems reflect the biases of their human makers, or make decisions that have biased implications.
SEE ALSO: People are fighting algorithms for a more just and equitable future. You can, too.In 2018, Twitter published a blog post that explained how it used a neural network to make photo previews decisions. One of the factors that causes the system to select a part of an image is higher contrast levels. This could account for why the system appears to favor white faces. This decision to use contrast as a determining factor might not be intentionally racist, but more frequently displaying white faces than black ones is a biased result.
There's still a question of whether these anecdotal examples reflect a systemic problem. But responding to Twitter sleuths with gratitude and action is a good place to start no matter what.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
Topics Artificial Intelligence X/Twitter
Previous:Cruelest Summer
Listen: Hemingway's Unrequited High School CrushOpenAI employees are pissed about Sam Altman departure. Here’s proof.In the age of TikTok, the female gaze has lost all meaningAre TikTok's deEthical, educational kinksters are out there — but maybe not on your FYP.Painting the American Dream at Guantánamo by Paige LainoBest deals of the day Jan. 27: 85Mark Twain’s Disturbing Passion for Collecting Young GirlsStaff Picks: Nerds, Necromancers and New Wave PoetryArt from Guantánamo by Erin ThompsonMark Twain’s Disturbing Passion for Collecting Young GirlsWhat Is the Political Responsibility of the Artist? by Taylor PlimptonDear Lynda: Diary Snoops and IllListen: Hemingway's Unrequited High School CrushBest Echo deal: Get an Echo Pop and a Kasa smart color bulb for under $18Google redesigned the Chrome Web Store and it actually looks pretty goodRedux: P. D. James, Walter Mosley, Georges Simenon by The Paris ReviewThe Literary Prize for the Refusal of Literary PrizesWordle today: The answer and hints for November 21Score Chromebooks for as low as $129 on Black Friday The user behind @x on Twitter has no idea what will happen after the X rebrand Illustrated author portmanteaux of the two Got a strange text about your COVID vaccine? Here's what it could be. Book News for January 13, 2014 Prince Philip has died at 99 Lysley Tenorio’s Window on the World Google is starting to roll out its Privacy Sandbox Microsoft is testing Bing Chat on Chrome and Safari The Last Call Killer: Everything you need to know Netflix is hiring an AI manager for up to $900K amid ongoing strikes Punning on Saul Bellow Punning on John Updike Samsung Galaxy Unpacked 2023 livestream: How to watch live Martin Amis Owes Everything to His “Wicked Stepmother,” and Other News by Dan Piepenbring Grindr employees are unionizing 'Jeopardy!' champions boycott to support the WGA strike Apple releases iOS 16.6 with a bunch of security fixes Siri Hates Her, and Other News This Library's Sign Admits What Book Lovers Seldom Do 16 brilliant innovations tackling poverty around the world
1.7681s , 10122.0625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【The Liar (2014)】,Fresh Information Network