New Jersey is Indiaahead of the curve — at least when it comes to stopping its law enforcement from using the creepy and potentially biased facial-recognition app Clearview AI.
The app, which scraped billions of photos from the likes of Facebook, YouTube, Venmo, and other online platforms, drew the world's attention last weekend following a detailed report in the New York Times. The app's supposed capability to identify practically anyone from even low-quality photos frightened privacy advocates and officials. And today, one of the latter — New Jersey's attorney general Gurbir Grewal — actually did something about it.
According to the ACLU of New Jersey, attorney general Grewal "put a moratorium on Clearview AI’s chilling, unregulated facial recognition software."
"AG asked that all law enforcement agencies in New Jersey stop using Clearview’s technology until we get a better handle on the situation," explained the New Jersey attorney general's director of communications, Sharon Lauchaire, over email. "We have communicated this request to the 21 County Prosecutors, and asked that they share it with all of the police departments and other law enforcement agencies within their respective jurisdictions."
Notably, Lauchaire told Mashable that her office is "not sure how long this process will take." In other words, Clearview AI may be on the outs in New Jersey for some time.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
This news was also confirmed by NJ.com, which reported Friday afternoon that Grewal ordered all New Jersey police to cease their use of the tool (at least for now).
The ACLU of New Jersey emphasized in its statement that facial-recognition technology, like Clearview AI, is problematic for all kinds of known and troubling reasons.
"Facial recognition tech has been trained on databases filled primarily with white, male faces," wrote the organization. "That leads to discrimination and false-positives of people of color, women, and non-binary people."
This rather alarming fact was recently confirmed by a federal study which found that "the highest false positives are in American Indians, with elevated rates in African American and Asian populations."
We reached out to Clearview AI for comment, but received no immediate response.
This is not the first of the company's troubles, nor do we imagine it will be the last. Just earlier this week, Twitter demanded that Clearview AI stop using any photos it had scraped from the social media platform, and a class action lawsuit is already in the works.
Meanwhile, in a statement on its site, Clearview AI insists that "Clearview is not a surveillance system and is not built like one."
It would appear New Jersey's attorney general would disagree.
UPDATE: Jan. 24, 2020, 5:10 p.m. PST:This story was updated to include comment from the New Jersey attorney general's director of communications, Sharon Lauchaire.
Topics Cybersecurity Facial Recognition Privacy
NYT Connections hints and answers for April 25: Tips to solve 'Connections' #684.
Golden Globes 2019: Check out the full list of nominees
The 10 best video games of 2018
Cows casually stroll through a woman's front yard in Scotland
Gods of War
Student wins class a perfect score on a chemistry test with an epic paper ball toss
Exam tests if students can identify their Asian teacher in a group
NFL fans lose it after Dolphins upend Patriots with a wild trick play
The internet is talking like Kevin from 'The Office' now
'Racist' cartoon gets Charlie Hebdo comparison by Aussie Press Council
Useful or Little Known Android Features
This may be the most brutally effective Facebook prank of all time
Allo, goodbye: Google is killing off the messaging app
Coinbase homepage ad reveals the sad state of the crypto market
Best Sony deal: Save $100 on WH
BTS member teases possible collab with Ed Sheeran, goes massively viral
15 holiday gifts that teachers will actually like
Latest victims of a Photoshop battle are bored millennials at state fair
Parental Controls: How to Lock Down Your Kids' iOS Devices
This Instagram artist's mock self
Metadata on U.S. government memos reveals authors linked to Project 2025'True Detective: Night Country': Is the long night a real thing?Redux: The Name like a Net in His Hands by The Paris ReviewArtifact news app is shutting down, one year postA Jackpot in the Archive by Christopher NotarnicolaRedux: The Modest Watercolor by The Paris ReviewEverything Writes Itself: An Interview with Black Thought by David MaCooking with Herman Melville by Valerie StiversRedux: Seventy Memories by The Paris ReviewKnow Thyself by Meghan O’GieblynAmerica’s Dead Souls by Molly McGheeStaff Picks: Dopamine, Magazines, and Exhaustive Guides from A to Z by The Paris ReviewRedux: About You I Know Only the Weight of a Little Ink by The Paris ReviewDid Trump's executive order just make everyone in the U.S. female?Every Poem Has Ancestors by Joy HarjoCooking with C. L. R. James by Valerie StiversStrawberry Moon by Nina MacLaughlinArtifact news app is shutting down, one year postPicture Books as Doors to Other Worlds by Elissa WashutaCES 2024: I got to try Ambarella's self Ted Hughes in “The Fouled Nest of the Industrial Revolution” How to update your Instagram app Best Prime Day Apple Watch deal: $50 off Apple Watch Ultra 2 On Lesley Blanch and Women Travel Writers The 10 best and funniest tweets of the week, including Elon Musk and the airport security line Vagrich Bakhchanyan and Subversive Soviet Art Staff Picks: Raymond Pettibon, Jane Campion, Maggie Doherty Amazon Prime Members get a free 3 Best Prime Day Nintendo Switch Deal: Mario Kart 8 bundle The Mr. Mantarian Subterfuge: A Story of Dog Boarding Sixty Years of The Paris Review’s Design: A History “More Rock and Roll! More Loud!” Giorgio Gomelsky, 1934–2016 Hiroki Tsukuda’s “Enter the O”: A Haunting Alternate Reality I Lost an Idea Last Night Remember the Oddity That Was “Closed on Account of Rabies”? Best cordless vacuum deal: Get the Dyson V11 Extra for $404.99 Linda Pastan Talks About Her New Collection, “Insomnia” Photography Incubabula: How Early Photographs Got in Books Best Apple Watch Prime Day deals C. D. Wright, 1949–2016; Read Her Poem “Our Dust”